What are the advantages and disadvantages of judicial precedent?

      

What are the advantages and disadvantages of judicial precedent?

  

Answers


Maurice
Advantages:
(i)Certainty and Predictability: InDodhia V. National and Grindlays Bankthe?
Court of Appeal was emphatic that “a system of law requires a considerable degree of certainty.” Case law makes a legal system certain and predictable.

(ii) Consistency and uniformity: case law facilitates consistency and uniformity in the administration of justice as similar cases are decided in alike.

(iii)Rich in detail: many decisions which constitute precedents have been made.

(iv) Practicality: judicial precedent is practical in that principles or propositions of law are formulated on the basis of practical circumstances that demand legal solutions.

(v) Flexibility: it is contended that case law is flexible in that judges in
subsequent cases attempt and sometimes succeed in distinguishing earlier
decisions so as to justify departing from them.

Disadvantages:
(i) Rigidity: strict application of judicial precedent makes a legal system inflexible and unresponsive to changes. This could perpetuate incorrect decisions.

(ii) Over-subtely: when judges in subsequent cases attempt to
distinguish indistinguishable cases so as to depart from them, they develop technical distinctions or distinctions without differences. This arguably makes caselaw artificial and may lead to uncertainty.

(iii) Bulky and complex: caselaw is by its nature bulky as many decisions have
been made and there is no index as to which of them are precedents in what cases.
Closely allied to this problem is the challenge of extracting the ratio decidendi.

(iv) Piece-meal: principles or propositions of law are enunciated by courts in bits
and pieces that is, there is no deliberate attempt to make law in a comprehensive matter.
maurice.mutuku answered the question on April 28, 2018 at 12:40


Next: Ratification where the principal adopts an unauthorized act of his agent as his own. What are the conditions which must be fulfilled for ratification to be...
Previous: Explain the requirements which local customs should fulfill in order to gain registration and enforcement by the courts.

View More CPA Commercial Law Questions and Answers | Return to Questions Index


Exams With Marking Schemes

Related Questions