K. Kemei want to buy a new car for G. N Motors Ltd. He selected a new and nice looking car and was informed by G....

      

K. Kemei want to buy a new car for G. N Motors Ltd. He selected a new and nice
looking car and was informed by G. N. Motors Ltd that the car was new and free from
any defects K. Kemei signed a sale agreement with the motor company which partly
read “…..no condition or warranty that the vehicle is road worthy or as to its age
or fitness for any purpose is given or implied by the seller. Goods once sold cannot be
returne.”
When the car was delivered to K. Kemei after paying for it, he discovered to his surprise that it
was a second hand car of the same make as the car he had selected but with several major
mechanical defects.
G. N Motors Ltd. insists that he sale was validly concluded and that they cannot be liable to K.
Kemei under any circumstances.

Advise Kemei.

  

Answers


Maurice
This problem is based on the enforcement of exemption clauses with specific reference to
fundamental breach or obligation theory, which is to the effect that an exemption clause will
not generally be given effect is doing so amounts to a fundamental breach or enables the
stronger party evade the fundamental obligation of the contract.

In this case K. Kemei bought a new and nice looking car from G.N. Motors Ltd, but the
motor vehicle supplied by the seller is fundamentally different in that is second hand and
has many mechanical defects.

This obviously amounts to a fundamental breach of contract by the company and K. Kemei
has reason to feel aggrieved.

Giving effect to the exemption clause would enable G.N. motors Ltd evade the
fundamental obligation of the contract.

My advise to K. Kemei is to refuse to take delivery of the motor vehicle and sue the
company in damages for the breach. The company cannot effectively rely on the exemption
clause as a defence.

My advise is based on the decision in Karsales (Harrow) Ltd V. Wallis whose facts were
substantially similar.
maurice.mutuku answered the question on May 3, 2018 at 06:50


Next: Discuss the rules that affect the effectiveness of exemption clauses.
Previous: Explain the principle of vicarious liability.

View More CPA Commercial Law Questions and Answers | Return to Questions Index


Exams With Marking Schemes

Related Questions