Foper Ltd. currently operates a 'top-down' budgeting system where senior managers impose budgets on departmental managers. The company is now considering allowing departmental managers to participate in...

      

Foper Ltd. currently operates a 'top-down' budgeting system where senior managers impose
budgets on departmental managers.
The company is now considering allowing departmental managers to participate in the setting of
their own budgets.

Required:

Argue the case for and against the participation of departmental managers in the preparation of their
budgets.

  

Answers


Martin
Argue the case for and against the participation of departmental managers in the
preparation of their budgets
Case For

(i) Managers will help to create and monitor a budget that will improve performance in their
department and the organization.

(ii) They will use the budget process as a planning tool to consistently meet and exceed
financial goals and expectations.

(iii) Managers will know how to determine profit margin and break-even points.

(iv) They will accurately judge the impact of expenses on projects and make forecasts on
performance.

Case against

(i) It may lead to creation of budget slack. Where managers are able to influence their budget
standard, there is a possibility that they will bias the information in order to gain the greatest
possible benefit. This will apply particularly where the reward system places great stress on
achieving the budget.

(ii) Participation may encourage managers to adopt a departmental self-centred approach and
concentrate solely on maximizing the benefits of their own departments at the expense of the
benefits of the organization as a whole.

(iii) The advantage of management participation may be negated by failure to implement the
budget by senior management leading to dissatisfaction similar to that experienced with
imposed budgets.

(iv) Such budgets may cause managers to introduce budgetary slacks ( A budgetary slack is a
margin set between what can be achieved and what managers state will be achieved)

(v) Managers may be unqualified to participate and therefore the budgets may be unachievable.
marto answered the question on February 22, 2019 at 08:42


Next: In the context of audit sampling, distinguish between the following terms: (i) Sampling risk and non-sampling risk (ii) Tolerable error and expected error (iii) Audit risk...
Previous: Explain the reliability of bank statements as audit evidence.

View More CPA Cost Accounting Questions and Answers | Return to Questions Index


Exams With Marking Schemes

Related Questions