Get premium membership and access questions with answers, video lessons as well as revision papers.
1. Civil and criminal liabilities.
An auditor could be sued in a civil court if he breaches his position of trust and confidentiality. E.g.
if he uses information acquired in course of an engagement for his financial gain or for benefit
of another party. Regarding criminal liability, section 136 of the companies Act provides that an
auditor shall be criminally liable if he willfully makes false statement in any report, certificate or
financial statements with an intention to deceive or mislead.
2. Liability to the client company under law of contract.
The audit client company represents all shareholders acting as a body (in this respect, a
company cannot be represented by a single shareholder). The auditor has a duty to report to the
shareholders whether the financial statements show a true and fair view. The auditor therefore
has a contract with the company. Under this contractual relationship, it is implied that the auditor
will carry out his work with a reasonable degree of care and skill. The degree of care and skill
required mainly depends on nature of work undertaken. Generally if the auditor has complied
with the GAAPs and guidance from the ISAs, it would be difficult to prove that the auditor was
negligent.
In the case of Kingston cotton mill, the judge considered the degree of care and skill required
of an auditor and declared that it is the duty of an auditor to bring to bear on the work he has to
perform, that skill, care and caution which a reasonably competent, cautious and careful auditor
would use.
The auditor has no duty to an individual shareholder. A shareholder who makes an investment
decision by relying on the auditor’s report and suffers financial loss cannot claim for damages
under the law of contract. Only if the company i.e. the entire body of shareholders has suffered
a loss can such a case be brought under law of contract .
3. Liability to third parties under tort or negligence.
In this case third parties refer to anyone other than the client company who has used the
auditor’s report and wishes to make a claim for negligence. It therefore includes any individual
shareholders in the company, any potential invertors and other providers of capital such as
lenders and creditors. The difference between these parties and the client company is that such
third parties have no contract with the auditor and therefore no implied duty of care.
For third parties to succeed in claiming for damages under negligence, they must prove that;
• A duty of care existed i.e. the auditor owed the third parties a duty of care.
• The duty of care was breached through auditor’s negligence.
• They suffered a financial loss as a direct consequence of an auditor’s negligence.
In Hedley Byrne and Company Limited versus Heller and Partners (1963), it was held that ‘a duty
of care exists where there is a special relationship between the parties. I.e. where the auditor
knew or ought to have known that the financial statements would be made available and would
be relied upon by a particular person.’ The implication of this statement is that, for there to exist
a duty of care, the third part must have been identified in some way to the auditor. E.g. where
the directors inform the auditor that the financial statements would be used to obtain a loan, the
auditor will have to owe duty of care to the bank in the same way he owes a duty of care to the
client.
Wilfykil answered the question on April 11, 2019 at 08:59
- Discuss criminal law and the auditor(Solved)
Discuss criminal law and the auditor
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Define International Standards on Auditing(Solved)
Define International Standards on Auditing
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- List the properties of a statutory audit that are different from a private audit.(Solved)
List the properties of a statutory audit that are different from a private audit.
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Discuss the Assertion Methodology(Solved)
Discuss the Assertion Methodology
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- When will financial statements present a true and fair view?(Solved)
When will financial statements present a true and fair view?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- What do auditors consider before appropriately testing whether an item is material or not?(Solved)
What do auditors consider before appropriately testing whether an item is material or not?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Which are the factors necessitating growth in Internal Audit?(Solved)
Which are the factors necessitating growth in Internal Audit?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Which are the limitations of an Internal Audit?(Solved)
Which are the limitations of an Internal Audit?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- What are the advantages of Internal Audit function?(Solved)
What are the advantages of Internal Audit function?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Explain on external auditor’s reliance on work of internal auditor(Solved)
Explain on external auditor’s reliance on work of internal auditor
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- What is the Scope and Objectives of Internal audit function?(Solved)
What is the Scope and Objectives of Internal audit function?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Show the comparison between internal auditing and external auditing(Solved)
Show the comparison between internal auditing and external auditing
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- What is the Similarity between Auditing and Financial Accounting?(Solved)
What is the Similarity between Auditing and Financial Accounting?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Give the differences between Auditing and Financial Accounting(Solved)
Give the differences between Auditing and Financial Accounting
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Which are the disadvantages of auditing?(Solved)
Which are the disadvantages of auditing?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Give the advantages of auditing(Solved)
Give the advantages of auditing
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Define the term Financial Reporting framework(Solved)
Define the term Financial Reporting framework
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- Define the term Financial Statement(Solved)
Define the term Financial Statement
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- What is the definition an Audit?(Solved)
What is the definition an Audit?
Date posted: April 11, 2019. Answers (1)
- What are the purposes of audit engagement letter?(Solved)
What are the purposes of audit engagement letter?
Date posted: March 13, 2019. Answers (1)