Pros and Cons of Collective Bargaining

Answers

General advantages and disadvantages of collective bargaining
Pros
Can lead to high-performance workplace where labor and management jointly engage in problem solving, addressing issues on an equal standing.
• Provides legally based bilateral relationship.
• Management’s rights are clearly spelled out.
• Employers’ and employees’ rights protected by binding collective bargaining
agreement.
• Multi-year contracts may provide budgetary predictability on salary and other
compensation issues.
• Unions may become strong allies in protecting higher education from the
effects of an economic slowdown.
• Promotes fairness and consistency in employment policies and personnel decisions within and across institutions.
• Employees may choose whether they want union representation.
• A strong labor management partnership may enable the workforce development needed for engaging the technology revolution.

Cons
Management’s authority and freedom are much more restricted by negotiated rules.
• Creates significant potential for polarization between employees and managers.
• Disproportionate effect of relatively few active employees on the many in
the bargaining unit. This is particularly the case when collective bargaining
involves a system-wide structure of elections.
• Increases bureaucratization and requires longer time needed for decision making.
• Increases participation by external entities (e.g., arbitrators, State Labor Relations Board) in higher education’s decision making.
• Protects the status quo, thereby inhibiting innovation and change. This is
particularly the case when the change involves privatizations.
• More difficult for employees at smaller campuses to have their voices heard.
• Higher management costs associated with negotiating and administering the
agreements.
• Eliminates ability of management to make unilateral changes in wages, hours,
and other terms and conditions of employment.
• Restricts management’s ability to deal directly with individual employees.
• Increased dependence on the private sector for certain services, particularly
those requiring technological competence, may be compromised.
• Contract administration is a very difficult process to manage and significantly
changes the skill set required of managers and supervisors

Titany answered the question on December 3, 2021 at 06:15

Next: Levels of Collective Bargaining
Previous: Factors necessary for effective disciplinary system in an organization

View More Employee Relations Questions and Answers | Return to Questions Index

Pros and Cons of Collective Bargaining

Answers

Exams With Marking Schemes

Related Questions